Der Dutchman Plain City - Online Ordering

Der Dutchman Plain City
445 South Jefferson Avenue, Plain City, OH
Featured Items

Turkey Manhattan
Hot roast turkey sandwich served with mashed potatoes and covered with gravy$13.99
Family Meal for 4
Your choice of one meat, two quart sides, & dinner rolls.$46.99
Peanut Butter Cream Pie-Slice
$4.99
Lunch & Dinner
Limited Time Menu

Pork Tenderloin Sandwich
A hand-breaded pork loin cutlet fried golden and crispy, served on a bun and topped with house-made coleslaw. Served with your choice of one side.$13.99
Patty Melt
A juicy beef patty topped with melted Swiss cheese, caramelized onions, and Thousand Island dressing on grilled sourdough bread. Served with your choice of one side.$13.99
Chicken & Waffles
A golden Belgian waffle topped with two crispy chicken breasts, served with honey butter and hot honey for the perfect sweet-and-spicy finish.$14.49
Pumpkin Cheesecake-Slice
Creamy New York-style cheesecake blended with real pumpkin and warm fall spices, topped with whipped topping and a dusting of cinnamon.$5.99
Chicken Dinners
Dinners include choice of two side dishes.

Broasted Chicken Dinner
Broasted chicken is marinated, breaded and broasted under pressure – crispy outside, juicy inside$16.49
Chicken Wings Dinner
6 broasted chicken wings$15.99
Grilled Chicken Breast Dinner
Marinated boneless chicken breast$15.99
Smothered Chicken Breast Dinner
Marinated boneless chicken breast smothered with Swiss cheese, mushrooms and bacon$18.49
Chicken Tenders Dinner
4 crispy fried chicken tenders$15.99
Beef Dinners
Includes choice of two side dishes.

Chopped Sirloin Dinner
8oz Seasoned and charbroiled chopped sirloin$17.49
Loaded Chopped Sirloin Dinner
8oz Seasoned chopped sirloin charbroiled and loaded with Swiss cheese, mushrooms, and onions$18.99
Liver & Onions Dinner
Grilled beef liver topped with grilled onions$14.99
Roast Beef Dinner
Old-fashioned slow-roasted in its own juices$18.99
Meatloaf Dinner
A traditional Amish-style recipe$17.99
Turkey & Pork Dinners
Includes choice of two side dishes.

Ham Dinner
Grilled or baked.$16.99
Roast Pork Dinner
Slow-roasted to perfection in its own juices.$16.99
Roast Turkey Dinner
Old-fashioned slow-roasted turkey.$17.99
Seafood Dinners
Includes choice of two side dishes.

Cod Dinner
Mild cod filet, hand-breaded and deep-fried$20.99
Salmon Dinner
8oz filet, grilled tender, lightly seasoned or blackened$21.99
Shrimp Dinner
8 pieces of butterfly shrimp, lightly breaded and deep-fried to perfection$19.99
Seafood Platter
4oz fried cod and 5 pieces of deep-fried butterfly shrimp, served with hushpuppies, fries and coleslaw$21.99
Favorites

Noodles over Mashed Potatoes
Noodles ladled over made-from-scratch mashed potatoes$11.79
Chicken Stir Fry
Sauteed vegetables and grilled chicken served over a bed of rice with a side of teriyaki sauce.$17.99
Roast Beef Manhattan
Hot roast beef sandwich served with mashed potatoes and covered with gravy$13.99
Pork Manhattan
Hot roast pork sandwich served with mashed potatoes and covered with gravy$13.99
Turkey Manhattan
Hot roast turkey sandwich served with mashed potatoes and covered with gravy$13.99
Meatloaf Manhattan
Hot roast beef sandwich served with mashed potatoes and covered with gravy$13.99
Sandwiches
Served on homemade bread or a bun, with choice of one side dish.

B.L.T
Bacon, crisp lettuce and tomato served on white or wheat toast$13.99
BBQ Beef Sandwich
Juicy pulled pork smothered in our homemade BBQ sauce$14.99
BBQ Pork Sandwich
Juicy pulled pork smothered in our homemade BBQ sauce$13.99
Cheeseburger
Beef patty topped with American cheese$14.49
Chicken Salad Croissant
A tasteful mix of tender chicken, onion, and celery with our original sauce$14.99
Cod Sandwich
Hand-breaded and deep-fried cod filet$15.99
Dutchman Burger
8oz Chopped sirloin topped with Swiss cheese$14.99
Grilled Cheese
Famous & local Guggisberg Baby Swiss with thick slices of our homemade bread$10.99
Grilled Chicken B.L.T.
Boneless grilled chicken breast with bacon, lettuce and tomato$15.99
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Boneless grilled chicken breast$14.49
Grilled Ham & Cheese
Old fashioned grilled ham with your choice of cheese$13.49
Ham & Turkey Club
A classic triple-decker stacked with turkey, ham, crispy, and Swiss cheese, layered with lettuce and tomato on toasted white bread$14.99
Meatloaf Sandwich
Make from scratch meatloaf served on our homemade bread$13.99
Rachel Sandwich
Slow-roasted turkey with sauerkraut, Swiss cheese and Thousand Island dressing on rye bread$14.49
Reuben Sandwich
Corned-beef with sauerkraut, Swiss cheese and Thousand Island dressing on rye bread$14.49
Trail Bologna Sandwich
Troyer’s Trail Bologna served hot or cold with Guggisberg Baby Swiss$13.49
Veggie Burger
Chargrilled all-vegetable patty with a hint of spice$13.79
Side Dishes
A la Carte

Applesauce-Side
$4.29
Baked Sweet Potato-Side
$4.79
Broccoli-Side
$4.29
Coleslaw-Side
$4.29
Cottage Cheese-Side
$4.29
Creamed Corn-Side
$4.29
Dressing-Side
Served with beef or chicken gravy$4.29
French Fries-Side
$4.29
Fresh Fruit-Side
$4.79
Green Beans-Side
$4.29
Mac & Cheese-Side
$4.29
Macaroni Salad-Side
$4.29
Mashed Potatoes-Side
Served with beef or chicken gravy$4.29
Noodles-Side
Cooked in chicken broth$4.29
Onion Rings-Side
$4.79
Potato Salad-Side
$4.29
Potato Wedges-Side
$4.79
Red Beets-Side
$4.29
Sweet Potato Fries-Side
$4.79
Vegetable Blend-Side
$4.29
Salads

Strawberry Poppyseed Salad
Spinach & romaine topped with candied pecans, strawberries, feta cheese and charbroiled chicken breast. Served with poppy seed dressing$16.49
Chef Salad
Crisp lettuce, hardboiled egg, cheese, tomato, onion, croutons, and your choice of grilled chicken breast, ham, turkey, chicken tenders or roast beef$15.99
Soups

Chicken Noodle Soup
Heartwarming chicken broth with Essenhaus noodles and vegetables$4.49
Vegetable Beef Soup
Hearty beef broth with roast beef and a medley of vegetables$4.49
Family-Style
Family Meals
Family-sized comfort meals perfect for feeding your family

Family Meal for 2
Your choice of one meat, two pint sides, & dinner rolls.$24.99
Family Meal for 4
Your choice of one meat, two quart sides, & dinner rolls.$46.99
Family Meal for 8
Your choice of one meat, four quart sides, & dinner rolls.$89.99
Family Meal for 12
Your choice of one meat, six quart sides, & dinner rolls.$128.99
Buckets of Chicken
Mixed bucket comes with breast, thigh, leg, and wing. Must be ordered in increments of 4 assorted pieces. All white or all dark meat, add 25%

4 Pieces Chicken
$10.99
8 Pieces Chicken
2 Breasts, 2 Thighs, 2 Legs, & 2 Wings$19.49
12 Pieces Chicken
3 Breasts, 3 Thighs, 3 Legs, & 3 Wings$28.49
16 Pieces Chicken
4 Breasts, 4 Thighs, 4 Legs, & 4 Wings$36.99
20 Pieces Chicken
5 Breasts, 5 Thighs, 5 Legs, & 5 Wings$44.99
Chicken Wings & Tenders

5 Pieces Chicken Wings
$8.49
10 Pieces Chicken Wings
$14.49
20 Pieces Chicken Wings
$25.49
6 Chicken Tenders
$12.99
12 Chicken Tenders
$23.99
Meats by the Pound

Roast Beef by Pound
Lb$19.49
Baked Ham by Pound
Lb$15.49
Roast Pork by Pound
Lb$15.49
Roast Turkey-Mix by Pound
Lb$17.49
Roast Turkey - White Meat by Pound
Lb$18.49
Family-Sized Side Dishes
Perfectly portioned, homemade sides—great for adding to any meal or ordering extra to enjoy later. Choose your favorite from the options below.
Pint-Size Hot Sides
Bring home a pint of our comforting hot side dishes, perfect for adding to your meal or sharing with the family. Serves approximately 2-3 people.$6.99Quart-Size Hot Sides
Take home a generous quart of our comforting hot side dishes, perfect for family meals, gatherings, or leftovers. Serves 4-6 people.$11.99Pint-Size Cold Sides
Enjoy our delicious chilled side dishes in a convenient pint size, perfect for a smaller gathering or an extra side at home. Serves 2-3 people.$6.99Quart-Size Cold Sides
Take home a quart of your favorite chilled side dishes, perfect for sharing or enjoying later. Serves 4-6 people.$11.99Pint-Size Soups
Enjoy a pint of our comforting, hearty soup—perfect for a quick meal or a cozy addition to your day. Serves 2-3 people.$6.99Quart-Size Soups
Take home a generous quart of our hearty, homemade soup, perfect for sharing or enjoying later. Serves 4-6 people.$11.99
Beverages
Fountain Drinks

Pepsi
$3.49
Pepsi Zero
$3.49
Diet Pepsi
$3.49
Mountain Dew
$3.49
Diet Mountain Dew
$3.49
Dr. Pepper
$3.49
Root Beer
$3.49
Starry
$3.49
Raspberry Iced Tea
$3.49
Lemonade
$3.49
Coffee & Tea

Regular Coffee
$3.29
Decaf Coffee
$3.29
Hot Tea
$3.29
Sweet Iced Tea
$3.49
Unsweet Iced Tea
$3.49
Half Tea / Half Lemonade
$3.49
Juice

Orange Juice
$3.99
Apple Juice
$3.99
Grape Juice
$3.99
Cranberry Juice
$3.99
Tomato Juice
$3.99
Grapefruit Juice
$3.99
Milk

Chocolate Milk
$3.99
White Milk
$3.99Buttermilk
$3.99
Dessert
Cream Pies by the Slice

Banana Cream Pie-Slice
$4.99
Butterscotch Cream Pie-Slice
$4.99
Chocolate Cream Pie-Slice
$4.99
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cream Pie-Slice
$4.99
Coconut Cream Pie-Slice
$4.99
Peanut Butter Cream Pie-Slice
$4.99
Red Raspberry Cream Pie-Slice
$4.99
Baked Pies by the Slice

Apple Pie-Slice
$4.99
Blackberry Pie-Slice
$4.99
Black Raspberry Pie-Slice
$5.49
Blueberry Pie-Slice
$4.99
Cherry Pie-Slice
$4.99
Custard Pie-Slice
$4.99
Dutch Apple Pie-Slice
$4.99
German Chocolate Pie-Slice
OUT OF STOCK$5.49
Lemon Meringue Pie-Slice
$4.99
Peach Pie-Slice
$4.99
Ice Cream

Vanilla Ice Cream
$3.99
Chocolate Ice Cream
$3.99Choc & Vanilla Twist Ice Cream
$3.99
Ice Cream Sundae
Chocolate or Caramel$4.99
Cookie a la Mode
Chocolate chip cookie and ice cream topped with hot fudge and whipped topping$4.99
Other Favorites

Pumpkin Cheesecake-Slice
Creamy New York-style cheesecake blended with real pumpkin and warm fall spices, topped with whipped topping and a dusting of cinnamon.$5.99
Bread Pudding
Homemade bread pudding with caramel sauce$4.99
Chocolate Chip Cookie
$1.69
Kid's
Kids Meals
Ages 10 and under.

Kids-Chicken Dinner
Choose two chicken fingers, two drumsticks or grilled chicken breast$8.29
Kids-Roast Turkey Dinner
$9.29
Kids-Roast Beef Dinner
$9.29
Kids-Mini Corn Dogs
Mini corn dogs$8.29
Kids-Macaroni & Cheese
$8.29
Kids-Cheeseburger
Beef patty topped with cheese on a homemade bun$8.29
Kids-Grilled Cheese
$8.29
Cafe Drinks Menu
Coffee

Dutchman Signature Blend
from our dining room$3.29Iced Coffee
$4.496:01 AM
Dutchman signature blend, espresso$4.99Cappuccino
Espresso, frothed milk$4.49Cafe Latte
Espresso, steamed milk$4.99Cafe Americano
Espresso with hot water$4.49Espresso Double Shot
$1.49
Tea & Cocoa
Hot Cocoa
$4.49Flavored Cocoa
$4.99Steamer
Espresso with hot water$4.49Bigelow Tea
Bigelow tea selection$3.29Chai Tea Latte
Black tea, vanilla, spices, honey, milk; served hot, cold or blended$4.99
Smoothies
Our smoothie mix blended with ice creates a refreshingly cold, thick, and creamy drink.

Mango Smoothie
Ripe mango blended smooth for a bright, tropical drink with naturally sweet flavor.$6.49
Peach Smoothie
Sweet, juicy peaches blended smooth for a refreshing, naturally fruity drink.$6.49
Pina Colada Smoothie
A creamy, tropical Piña Colada Smoothie blended with sweet, juicy pineapple and smooth coconut for a perfect island-inspired treat. Every sip is rich, fruity, and delightfully refreshing.$6.49
Strawberry Banana Smoothie
A classic combo of sweet strawberries and creamy bananas blended smooth for a refreshingly fruity treat.$6.49
Strawberry Smoothie
Juicy strawberries blended smooth for a naturally sweet and refreshing drink.$6.49
Wild Berry Smoothie
A vibrant blend of juicy wild berries, perfectly smooth for a sweet and slightly tangy refreshment.$6.49
Favorites

Buckeye Latte
Espresso, chocolate sauce, peanut butter syrup, steamed milk, whipped cream$5.99
Dutch Caramel Latte
Espresso, caramel sauce, steamed milk, whipped cream$5.99
Dutch Mocha
Espresso, chocolate sauce, steamed milk, whipped cream$5.99
Salted Caramel Latte
Espresso, caramel sauce, steamed milk, whipped cream$5.99
White Chocolate Mocha
Espresso, white chocolate sauce, steamed milk, whipped cream$5.99
White Chocolate Raspberry Truffle
Espresso, white chocolate sauce, raspberry syrup, steamed milk, whipped cream$5.99
Bakery
Cream Pies - Large

Banana Cream Pie-LG
$15.49
Butterscotch Cream Pie-LG
$15.49
Chocolate Cream Pie-LG
$15.49
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cream Pie-LG
$15.49
Coconut Cream Pie-LG
$15.49
Peanut Butter Cream Pie-LG
$15.49
Red Raspberry Cream Pie-LG
$16.99
Dinner Rolls

White Dinner Rolls-12PK
$5.19
White Dinner Rolls-6PK
$4.19
Wheat Dinner Rolls-12PK
$5.19
Wheat Dinner Rolls-6PK
$4.19
Der Dutchman Peanut Butter Spread
Thick, sweet, and creamy, Amish peanut butter spread is perfect on homemade bread.$5.99+
Der Dutchman Apple Butter
A sweetly spicy treat made from locally grown apples in the heart of Amish Country.$3.99+
Cookies - 6 pack

Chocolate Chip Cookies-6PK
$7.49
Monster Cookies-6PK
$7.49
Peanut Butter Cookies-6PK
$7.49
Snickerdoodle Cookies-6PK
$7.49